You are viewing this site in staging mode. Click in this bar to return to normal site.
x#{notify_img}
#{notify_title}
#{notify_text}

Charles Hodge Part 1

15 November 2026 09:20

Charles Hodge – Part 1

 

This is the first in a series of three posts on Charles Hodge of Princeton. It begins with a brief sketch of his life. Then, in the remaining part, and in the two articles to follow, we take a more topical approach. We look at Hodge in a series of different lights – in various family relations; in his friendships; as a preacher, teacher, and editor; in controversy; as an exegete and as a theologian; and finally as a Christian man. We discover, in doing so, what an outstanding figure he was.  

 

An overview of his life

Charles Hodge was born in Philadelphia in December 1797.  He was the fifth and last child of Hugh and Mary Hodge, his father sadly surviving him by only a few months.  Three of the children had died before Charles was born.  The only one remaining was his brother, Hugh, who was 18 months old at the time. Hugh became a doctor and lived until 1873.  Throughout his life he and Charles were very close to each other. 

 After attending various schools, Charles entered Princeton College – better known at the time as the College of New Jersey.  The year was 1812, the same year in which Princeton Theological Seminary was founded.  During his time as a student at college, Hodge made a public profession of faith by joining the Presbyterian Church at Princeton.  The date was January 13, 1815.  There is very little information as to the background to this profession of faith. In a fragment of autobiography Hodge says, ‘There has never been anything remarkable in my religious experience unless it be that it began very early.  I think that in my childhood I came nearer to conforming to the apostle’s injunction “pray without ceasing” than in any other period of my life.  As far back as I can remember I had the habit of thanking God for everything I received and asking him for everything I wanted’.  One of Hodge’s friends, Kensey John Van Dyke, who was in the class below him at college, made a public profession at the same time.  The impact on their fellow students was considerable.  There was in fact a revival amongst the students and the public stand for Christ taken by these two young men was recognised as being a contributing factor. 

 Hodge graduated from Princeton College in September 1815.  For the sake of his health he then took a year out from formal study and in November 1816 matriculated as a student at Princeton Seminary.  He had wanted to enter the gospel ministry for many years and but for the advice of others would have entered seminary as soon as he finished college.  It is clear, however, that he was not labouring under romantic notions as to what life in the ministry would be like.  In a letter to his mother in the summer of 1816, just a few months before beginning his theological studies, he writes, ‘It is the profession, I know, in which generally speaking there is the least prospect of earthly happiness, since there are so many deprivations and inconveniences to which those who embrace it must submit as they must be ever so much more at the disposition of others than of themselves.  Yet I feel that it is the only one in which I could be happy, believing it to be the path of my duty’. 

 His two professors in the seminary were Dr. Archibald Alexander, who during the first year of the seminary’s life had been sole instructor, and Dr. Samuel Miller, who had taken up his post in December 1813.  For these two men, alongside whom it would be his privilege to work for many years, Hodge had the highest regard and love.  To Dr. Alexander, as we shall see, he was especially close.

 Hodge graduated from Princeton Seminary in September 1819 at the age of 21.  Before he did so something happened which ultimately determined the whole future course of his working life.  It was the morning of May 6 and Hodge happened to call on Dr. Alexander in his study. ‘After the business which brought him had been transacted’, writes his son and biographer, A.A. Hodge, ‘Dr. Alexander without preparation suddenly said, “How would you like to be a professor in the seminary?”  Our father often in after years told us that this question overwhelmed him with surprise and confusion.  The thought had never entered his imagination before’.

 At the church’s General Assembly the following year, 1820, it was resolved ‘that the professors be authorized to employ an assistant teacher of the original languages of Scripture’.  With that authority having been obtained, Hodge was promptly appointed.  He began to teach in the seminary in November 1820, the beginning of an association with Princeton which was to last until his death 58 years later.  His subjects were Hebrew and Greek. In a letter to his brother shortly after beginning he says, ‘I never knew until I undertook it, that hearing a class of 20 or 30 students recite is one of the most fatiguing things in the world.  The unbroken attention you are obliged to pay for an hour and a half together is more tiresome than anyone who has not felt it would imagine’. 

 His position as teacher changed at the General Assembly of 1822 to that of Professor of Oriental and Biblical Literature, a chair he retained until 1840.  Each morning he would teach and lecture on Hebrew language, literature, and exegesis and in the afternoons on New Testament literature and exegesis.  Extensive courses were also given on biblical criticism, hermeneutics, and the exegesis of several biblical books.  A month after his election, on June 17, 1822, Hodge married Miss Sarah Bache, a young lady whom he had known and loved for many years.  She was two years his junior and for the twenty seven and a half years of their married life they were wonderfully happy together. 

 

In October 1826 Hodge took a two-year break from teaching, his time being largely spent in private study in Germany.  He had increasingly been feeling the need for such study.  In a letter to his brother he could say, ‘I feel constantly the most painful sense of unfitness for my work and the conviction that with nothing more than fragments of time at command, I can make little progress.  My plan, therefore, is to apply to the Board of Directors for permission to spend two years in Europe’.

 

The account of this time abroad, first in France and then at greater length in Germany, occupies nearly a hundred pages of Hodge’s biography. The details are largely taken from the journals that he kept when he was abroad and are deeply interesting.  He met many of the key German theologians of the day – Hengstenberg, Neander, Tholuck, Gesenius – and he formed a number of deep and lasting friendships.  He also survived his prolonged exposure to the theological liberalism which was so rife in Germany at that time.  His friends back home were very anxious about this.  ‘The air which you breathe in Germany’, wrote Dr. Alexander on one occasion, ‘will either have a deleterious effect on your moral constitution or else by the strength of faith required to resist this effect, your spiritual health will be confirmed.  I pray God to keep you.  I wish you to come home enriched with biblical learning but abhorring German philosophy and theology’. And so by the grace of God it proved. 

 

At the General Assembly in 1840, due to Dr. Alexander’s advancing age, Dr. Hodge, as he was by this time, was elected professor of Exegetical and Didactic Theology.  It was a change for which he had little enthusiasm.  ‘To you’, he writes to his brother, ‘I may say in confidence that I would give $5,000, if I had them, to be let off.  The new arrangement knocks all my plans on the head and will increase my official labours for years to come four-fold’.  ‘This feeling’, comments his son, ‘is remarkable in consideration of the fact that from our point of view, his natural qualifications for the attainment of eminent excellence and usefulness in this new chair’ – in which he would be teaching theology – ‘were far greater than any he possessed for the attainment of the same rank in the old one’ – in which, as we have seen, he taught biblical languages and exegesis.  His new work involved him in two things – delivering exegetical lectures to the Junior class on the Pauline epistles (which he had been doing before) and teaching Systematic Theology.  In these he continued until his death at the age of 80 in 1878.

 Some glimpses of family relations

Taking now a more topical approach to Hodge’s life, we start with some glimpses of family relations. His mother died in 1832 when he was 34 years of age and to the very end of his life he retained a deep sense of gratitude toward her.  As he approached his 70th birthday, for example, he could say to his brother, ‘What a mother we had to watch over our infancy and train our youth and secure for us at such sacrifice to herself a liberal education’.  More movingly, in his 80th year he could write, ‘It is no marvel that mothers are sacred in the eyes of their children. The debt they owe them is beyond all estimate. To our mother, my brother and myself under God, owe absolutely everything.  To us she devoted her life. For us she prayed, laboured and suffered’. 

 It was a gratitude that had long been felt.  Back in 1826, for example, he could say in a letter to his mother, ‘Every day that I live I feel more deeply the extent of my obligations to you, for every day I become more sensible of the value of the education which your disinterested exertions secured your children, and of the restraints and counsels which kept our youthful feet from the paths of the destroyer.  It is one of my daily subjects of thankfulness that God has given us such a mother’. 

 His mother, as we noted, had five children, only two of them surviving: Charles and his older brother Hugh. The two brothers had the closest of relationships. ‘They were only 18 months apart in age’, says A.A. Hodge, ‘and in childhood and youth had been all in all to each other. They were one in principles, opinions and interests – temporal and spiritual’, and for years they wrote to each other every week. 

 Hugh, being a doctor, was much better off than Charles and was very generous in his support of him. ‘No professor in Princeton’, says Charles, ‘was ever able to bring up and educate a family of children on his salary. My brother, without waiting to be asked, always helped me through. He seemed to regard me as himself and my children as his own’. 

 Hodge’s wife, Sarah, died on Christmas Day, 1849, at the age of 51. It was the greatest sorrow of his life. ‘For 27 years God spared us to each other and no man had ever more reason than I have had to rejoice in the unwavering affection of a most superior woman’.  Eighteen months after her death he could write, ‘No day has intervened that I have not often and literally shed tears to her memory; no week has passed that I have not been twice or oftener to her grave’.  On July 8, 1852, he married again, this time to a widow called Mary Hunter Stockton who had long been a close friend of the family. ‘This noble Christian lady’, writes his son, ‘supported and brightened all his later life and assiduously attended him with her tender ministrations until his eyes closed in death’. 

 By his first wife, Sarah, Charles had eight children – three daughters and five sons – all of whom he saw growing to maturity and professing faith in Christ. In one of the loveliest parts of the biography his son reflects back on their childhood days. ‘The children’, he says, ‘were at every age and at all times allowed free access to him.  If they were sick, he nursed them.  If they were well, he played with them.  If he were busy, they played about him.  His study had two doors, one opening outwards toward the seminary for the convenience of the students and the second one opening inward into the main hall of the house. Hence his study was always the family thoroughfare through which the children, boys and girls, young and old, and after them the grandchildren, went in and out for work and play.  When he was too lame to open the door, and afterwards when he was too busy to be interrupted by that action, he took the latch from the doors and caused them to swing in obedience to gentle springs so that the least child might toddle in at will unhindered. He prayed for us all in family prayers, and singly, and taught us to pray at his knees with such soul-felt tenderness that however bad we were, our hearts all melted to his touch…But that which makes these days sacred in the retrospect of his children is the person and character of the father himself as discovered in the privacy of his house, all radiant as that was with love, with unwavering faith, and with unclouded hope’. 

 In later years his great delight was in his grandchildren.  Two lots of grandchildren lived in the same village as himself ‘and made as free of his study and of the arms of his great chair’, we are told, ‘as his own children had done a generation earlier’. ‘He was always on the alert in providing presents for them’, says his son, ‘on all of their anniversaries and birthdays and at Christmas, and in selecting and dispatching appropriate Valentines with a gleeful delight equal and like to that of the young recipients themselves’. Not surprisingly they loved their grandfather very much in return.